NFL Trade Deadline Grades: Who Won the DeForest Buckner, Quenton Nelson Deals?
Who Won the DeForest Buckner, Quenton Nelson Deals?
As the NFL trade deadline approached, teams scrambled to improve rosters. The most headline‑grabbing moves involved defensive tackle DeForest Buckner and offensive tackle Quenton Nelson. This article grades each trade, revealing which franchises gained the upper hand.
DeForest Buckner: A Defensive Upgrade for the Rams
The Los Angeles Rams acquired Buckner from the New York Giants in a trade that sent a 2025 second‑round pick and a 2024 seventh‑round pick to New York. Buckner, a former first‑round pick, brings veteran presence and a proven pass‑rushing ability. The Rams, looking to bolster their front line, gained a player who can immediately contribute in both run and pass defense. The trade is graded A‑ for the Rams, who now have a more balanced defensive line.
Quenton Nelson: The Titans Secure a Pro Bowl Tackle
The Tennessee Titans traded a 2025 first‑round pick and a 2025 third‑round pick to the Indianapolis Colts for Quenton Nelson. Nelson, a two‑time first‑team All‑Pro, is a cornerstone of the Titans’ offensive line. The move demonstrates the Titans’ commitment to protecting their quarterback and improving offensive consistency. The trade earns an A‑ for Tennessee, who now have a top‑tier tackle to anchor their line.
Other Notable Trades
Beyond Buckner and Nelson, several other deals shaped the trade landscape. Teams like the Buffalo Bills and the Green Bay Packers exchanged draft capital for veteran depth, while the Dallas Cowboys added a seasoned defensive back to shore up their secondary. Each trade was evaluated on player impact, draft value, and long‑term fit.
Overall Assessment
When grading the trades, the Rams and Titans stand out as the clear winners. Both teams addressed critical needs with players who can contribute immediately, while the trade partners received valuable draft assets for future rebuilding. The trade deadline proved to be a pivotal moment for teams willing to make bold moves.
Source: Fox Sports – NFL Trade Deadline Grades
Watch and listen free on JASTORM: Follow radio and video broadcasts free in the JASTORM app with your free account.