Cody Rhodes’ Surprising Twist: Selling His Soul to Simone Johnson

During a recent interview on What Do You Wanna Talk About?, Cody Rhodes revealed an unexpected alternate storyline he once considered while feuding with The Rock. Instead of the original “Sell Your Soul” angle that culminated in a showdown with The Final Boss, Rhodes imagined a darker path where his soul would be traded to Simone Johnson, formerly known as Ava in WWE.

From The Rock to Simone: A Different Narrative

Rhodes explained that the idea surfaced during a heated feud with The Rock. He envisioned a scenario where the stakes were personal and the outcome unpredictable. Rather than facing a generic antagonist, the storyline would pit Rhodes against Johnson, whose character had evolved dramatically since her WWE days. The twist would have added a layer of intrigue, turning a straightforward rivalry into a psychological battle over identity and legacy.

Why the Original Plan Was Chosen

While the alternate plan was compelling, the production team ultimately opted for the more conventional “Sell Your Soul” narrative. The final boss angle provided a clear antagonist and a dramatic climax that resonated with fans. Rhodes noted that the original storyline allowed for a satisfying payoff, whereas the Simone twist, though creative, might have complicated the overarching plot.

Impact on Fans and Storytelling

Fans who followed the feud were surprised to learn about the potential direction. The idea of Rhodes trading his soul to a former WWE star sparked discussions about character development and the boundaries of wrestling storytelling. It highlighted how creative teams weigh risk against narrative cohesion when crafting high‑stakes feuds.

Looking Ahead

Rhodes remains open to exploring unconventional angles in future storylines. His willingness to share the alternate plan underscores the collaborative nature of wrestling storytelling, where even discarded ideas can inspire fresh concepts. As the industry continues to evolve, such creative experiments may become more common, offering fans new ways to engage with their favorite superstars.

Source: Wrestling Headlines

Watch and listen free on JASTORM – Follow radio and video broadcasts free in the JASTORM app with your free account.