Who’s the NFL’s Top Star? Allen, Mahomes, or Garrett?

As the 2026 NFL season approaches, analysts and fans alike are debating who will lead the league’s elite. Josh Allen, Patrick Mahomes, and Myles Garrett have all delivered standout performances, but which of these superstars will emerge as the definitive top player? Below, we break down their recent impact, projected roles, and how they compare to the rest of the top‑10 list.

Josh Allen: The Dual‑Threat Quarterback

Allen’s 2025 campaign showcased his evolution from a solid passer to a dynamic dual‑threat. With a career‑high 4,500 passing yards and 35 touchdowns, he also added 1,200 rushing yards and 12 rushing scores. His ability to extend plays with his legs keeps defenses guessing, and his leadership has been pivotal in the Bills’ playoff push. Analysts predict that Allen will continue to refine his pocket presence while maintaining his explosive running game, keeping him in the conversation for the league’s top player.

Patrick Mahomes: The Playoff Powerhouse

Mahomes’ 2025 season was a masterclass in precision and playmaking. He threw for 4,800 yards, 45 touchdowns, and only 8 interceptions, while adding 300 rushing yards. His chemistry with receivers like Tyreek Hill and Jalen Hurts has produced high‑scoring games that keep the Chiefs in the spotlight. With a championship ring already on his résumé, Mahomes is poised to cement his legacy as the NFL’s premier quarterback.

Myles Garrett: The Defensive Dominator

Garrett’s impact on the field is measured in more than just sacks. In 2025, he recorded 18 sacks, 5 forced fumbles, and 2 defensive touchdowns. His presence on the defensive line forces opposing offenses to adjust their game plans, and his leadership in the locker room has been cited as a key factor in the Browns’ defensive resurgence. Garrett’s ability to disrupt the backfield makes him a prime candidate for the league’s top defensive player.

Comparing the Top 10: Context Matters

While Allen, Mahomes, and Garrett dominate headlines, the top‑10 list also includes versatile players such as a rising star wide receiver, a defensive tackle with a knack for turnovers, and a running back who balances yardage with pass‑catching ability. Each player brings a unique skill set that contributes to their team’s success, illustrating that the NFL’s best talent is spread across positions.

What’s Next for the 2026 Season?

As teams finalize their rosters, the 2026 season promises to be a showcase of elite talent. Whether it’s Allen’s arm and legs, Mahomes’ precision, or Garrett’s defensive dominance, fans can expect high‑stakes matchups and record‑breaking performances. The debate over who will be the top star will intensify as the season unfolds, but one thing is clear: the NFL’s best players are ready to make history.

Source: Fox Sports

Watch and listen free on JASTORM – Follow radio and video broadcasts free in the JASTORM app with your free account.