Yahoo! Sports

Which MLB team will trade for Tarik Skubal? Breaking down who can, who should and who will acquire Detroit’s ace

By Jake Mintz
July 29, 2026 7 Min Read
Comments Off on Which MLB team will trade for Tarik Skubal? Breaking down who can, who should and who will acquire Detroit’s ace

The trade deadline is around the corner, and with each passing day, the odds of a Tigers turnaround grow ever smaller. Detroit won Tuesday against Baltimore to move within 3.5 games of a wild-card spot but then blew a 7-0 lead to lose in extra innings Wednesday in what might’ve been Skubal’s final outing with Detroit. Unless the Tigers can conjure a hot streak before Monday’s trade deadline, the club might need to do the painful, necessary thing and trade back-to-back Cy Young and impending free agent Tarik Skubal.

Tigers president of baseball operations Scott Harris doesn’t have to pull the trigger on any deal until the last second and is likely to wait out the schedule to see if his team makes things interesting. But you better believe that he and his inner circle are already sketching out potential trade packages for the world-beating southpaw.

We don’t know exactly what Harris and Co. would want in a deal, but we can safely assume the Tigers wouldn’t be seeking a return built around low-level minor leaguers. This team intends to be competitive in 2027. That means high-level prospects or controllable, young big leaguers, particularly young arms.

With all that in mind, let’s roll through the other 29 ballclubs and evaluate how likely each one is as a Skubal landing spot.

This octet represents the bottom eight in terms of playoff odds, and all are mired in single digits. All should be selling or, at the very least, not buying. It’s more likely that Skubal retires from baseball to pursue a career in quidditch than that he pitches for any of these clubs in 2026.

Although Miami, Washington, Minnesota and St. Louis are all hovering close to playoff spots, the industry expects all four to adopt a thread-the-needle approach to this deadline. A little buying, a little selling, nothing Earth-shattering. That doesn’t sound very Skubal-y.

Besides the fact that swinging a blockbuster for the market’s top player isn’t exactly Cleveland’s M.O., it’s difficult to envision Detroit sending Skubal to such a significant in-division rival, even if for only a few months. Optics matter, at least a little.

It’s ridiculous to assert that a team couldn’t use Skubal; that’s blatantly untrue. The back-to-back Cy Young would probably start Game 1 of a playoff series for every single team in baseball. But these four teams have rotations replete with depth and frontline talent and would be better served focusing their attention and resources elsewhere.

Boston already needs to replace its initial deadline addition, infielder Curtis Mead, after the former National went on the IL after one game due to a fractured wrist. The Sox are looking for bats. The same is true for the Judge-less Yankees, who are also currently without Cody Bellinger and Giancarlo Stanton. Seattle seems primed to deal from its rotation surplus — maybe Emerson Hancock, maybe Luis Castillo — not add to it. The Pirates are desperate for anything resembling a viable late-inning reliever. Maybe they get Skubal to pitch the ninth?

You never want to advocate passivity, but the White Sox should not mortgage their future for two months of Skubal. Nor will they. Because while this season has been a wonderful surprise for the Sox, their window probably doesn’t open in earnest until 2027. That’s true even if they sneak into October this year. Chicago should and will be aggressive to add pitching before the deadline, but that likely comes in the form of a controllable arm such as the Mariners’ Hancock, Angels’ Reid Detmers, Mets’ Will Warren or Twins’ Joe Ryan.

It’s not that these teams, in a vacuum, couldn’t craft a worthy package. It’s that, when push comes to shove, they’ll almost certainly be outbid by an organization with a deeper farm or more compelling controllable assets. Crucially, none of these clubs has the type of young, big-league-level starting pitcher the Tigers would likely want back as part of the haul.

Could the Phillies use Skubal? Sure. Could they maybe build something alluring around Andrew Painter? Maybe. Is that the best assortment of players Scott Harris and Co. could acquire? Absolutely not. The win-now-or-die Astros and Padres also have little to offer; their farm systems are currently ranked 29th and 30th by FanGraphs.

Texas could, in theory, do something around top-15 prospect Sebastian Walcott. But the promising Bahamian shortstop has hardly played this season after undergoing elbow surgery, which would make an evaluation particularly difficult. Besides, unless Detroit absolutely adores Kumar Rocker and/or Jack Leiter, the Rangers don’t have that requisite young MLB arm.

Arizona has a bevy of interesting young position players — Tommy Troy, Ryan Waldschmidt, Tim Tawa — but very little to offer in terms of arms. That’s also the case for Baltimore, with all due respect to rookie Brandon Young.

No team in baseball could use Skubal more than Chicago. The Cubs have a dangerous lineup, a pack of reliable, if unspectacular, starters and the best team defense in the sport. Pitching injuries have decimated the top of this rotation all season, with Edward Cabrera, Cade Horton, Ben Brown and Justin Steele currently on the IL. Skubal would give this team the horse it needs to actually make some noise in October.

But there’s one crucial impediment to this lofty dream: Chicago’s undermanned farm system skews toward bats. Their best pitching prospect, Jaxon Wiggins, missed the start of this season due to an elbow issue and has been horrific in five Triple-A starts since returning. The Cubs could probably cobble together enough intriguing position players to pique Detroit’s interest, but given what the following teams can offer, it’s difficult to see how Skubal ends up on the North Side.

It would be a shock to see any of this trio miss out on the postseason. Their playoff odds currently sit at 97.6%, 98.1% and 99.7%, respectively. Reinforcing their rosters with a difference-maker such as Skubal makes oodles of sense.

Of these three, Atlanta has both the biggest need and the weakest farm system. In that way, the Braves are a more realistic version of the aforementioned Cubs. Since May 1, they rank 18th in rotation ERA with an uninspiring 4.40 mark. Both Spencers, Schwellenbach and Strider, have been nonfactors due to injury. That has left an obvious void at the top of Atlanta’s staff behind Chris Sale.

On Opening Day, it would’ve been tough to envision Atlanta putting together a good enough package to woo the Tigers, but this farm system has made impressive strides over the past few months. Canadian outfielder Eric Hartman has been one of the most out-of-nowhere breakout prospects in baseball, though he might be a bit too far away for Detroit’s liking. Still, the Braves might have just enough for a Skubal deal, thanks to their myriad promising hurlers: AJ Smith-Shawver, Cam Caminiti, Owen Murphy, JR Ritchie, Didier Fuentes.

We can group Tampa Bay and Milwaukee together. These two small-market organizations are immensely respected around the industry for their ability to compete year after year after year despite small payrolls. That said, neither team has won anything significant in October this decade, save for Tampa’s Covid Cup AL pennant in 2020.

If not now, when? Both the Rays and the Brewers hold comfortable division leads that should secure them postseason byes. Both, while skilled at run prevention, are probably a playoff starter or two short. And crucially, these might be the two best farm systems in the sport. These teams have the need and the prospect capital to get this done — but do they have the gumption, the gall, the guts?

Or will the Dodgers just blow them out of the water?

A scout recently told me: “If Andrew [Friedman] wants Skubal, he’ll get Skubal.”

Such is life for the charmed Dodgers president of baseball operations. FanGraphs’ most recent update included eight of the club’s prospects on its top 100 list, including seven in the top 57. That’s an outrageous embarrassment of riches, one that could easily form the backbone of a Skubal deal. Detroit could practically treat Los Angeles’ farm system like a farmers market and pick out the exact type of players they’d prefer. 

And it’s not just that the Dodgers have a consensus top-three farm system and zero financial constraints. The club also boasts an array of young, controllable, relatively proven arms — Justin Wrobleski, Emmet Sheehan, even Roki Sasaki — that they could move if so compelled.

Do they need Skubal? No, absolutely not. The Dodgers are already anticipating a rotation crunch come October. Blake Snell and Tyler Glasnow are working their way back from injury, as is Shohei Ohtani the pitcher. Yoshinobu Yamamoto and the ascendant Justin Wrobleski were both All-Stars. Sasaki recently appeared to turn a corner. Eric Lauer obviously wouldn’t make a postseason rotation, but he has been much better than you think. Adding Skubal to this mix would be opulent overkill, a gold-plated steering wheel on a Lamborghini.

Sounds like something the Dodgers would like.

Author

Jake Mintz

Follow Me
Other Articles